Four committee leaders wrote it, the White House endorsed it and a coalition running from business lobbies to climate groups urged a yes vote. Tribal Nations organized against it within days of its release.
The Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act 62 to 33 on Nov. 19 after a string of procedural votes that began Nov. 9, according to the Senate roll call record. The bill, S. 5653, rewrites federal permitting law for energy, mining and infrastructure projects.
Four senators wrote it: Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., Mike Lee, R-Utah, Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., and Martin Heinrich, D-N.M. They are the chairs and ranking members of the two committees that handle energy and environmental law. Capito introduced the bill Sept. 30.
The committees’ Republican majorities set out the goal in their announcements, which the Congressional Research Service cited. The Energy and Natural Resources majority said the bill would strengthen energy security by speeding permits for energy and mineral projects. The Environment and Public Works majority said it would deliver cheaper energy, more jobs and responsible growth.
The White House weighed in Nov. 9, the day of the first procedural vote. The Office of Management and Budget’s Statement of Administration Policy said the administration strongly supports passage and argued the current permitting system has blocked pipelines, power plants and mines. It said the president’s advisers would recommend he sign the bill.
The same statement backed the bill’s requirement that the grid costs created by very large data center power loads fall on the companies that cause them rather than on households and small businesses.
The final vote crossed party lines. The roll call shows 47 Republicans, 14 Democrats and independent Angus King of Maine voted yes. The Democrats were Chris Coons, John Fetterman, Ruben Gallego, Martin Heinrich, John Hickenlooper, Amy Klobuchar, Gary Peters, Jack Reed, Jacky Rosen, Brian Schatz, Chuck Schumer, Elissa Slotkin, Mark Warner and Sheldon Whitehouse.
Thirty Democrats and independent Bernie Sanders voted no, joined by Republicans Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota. Republicans Bill Cassidy, John Cornyn, Mitch McConnell and Tommy Tuberville and Democrat Chris Murphy did not vote.
Business groups pressed for passage. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce sent senators a key vote letter Nov. 18 urging a yes vote and commending the four authors by name.
An October coalition letter organized by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a property rights law firm, urged Congress to pass the bill without delay, citing property rights and energy abundance. The Abundance Institute published the letter.
Climate-focused groups joined. Citizens’ Climate Lobby endorsed the bill Oct. 7 and moved its fall volunteer lobbying to November to push for passage, according to its own bulletin. The Breakthrough Institute announced support the day the bill was introduced. The Institute for Progress published an Oct. 8 analysis defending the bill’s Tribal provisions.
County governments signed on as well. The National Association of Counties urged county leaders to call their senators in support, citing provisions that recognize counties as cooperating agencies in federal environmental reviews.
Tribal Nations led the opposition. Nine Tribal organizations, including the Native American Rights Fund, wrote Senate leadership Oct. 9 asking it to remove provisions that weaken Tribal consultation and protections for sacred places and cultural resources. NARF later asked Congress to hold the bill until the next Congress could consult with Tribal Nations.
The National Congress of American Indians urged senators to vote no on the Nov. 9 cloture vote. NCAI said Tribal Nations support permitting reform but that the bill was crafted behind closed doors, without a legislative hearing, committee markup or timely Tribal consultation, and that the authors’ amendment did not fix it.
Preservation and environmental groups joined them. The National Trust for Historic Preservation said Nov. 8 it remains strongly opposed to the bill’s historic preservation title. Appalachian Voices, a Virginia environmental nonprofit, told Congress in its federal lobbying disclosure that it opposes the bill over its Clean Water Act provisions.
Opposition also came from inside the Democratic caucus. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto, D-Nev., voted to open debate, then voted against final passage after the Senate kept the historic preservation title she had demanded be struck.
The 119th Congress ends Jan. 3, 2027, and any bill it does not finish dies with it. NARF asked Congress to wait for the next one. The bill’s four authors, the White House and the Chamber need the House to act before then.
Discover more from KVIG Informative
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
