A $5.1 Million Fix to Duck Valley’s Water Settlement Now Waits on the House

Congress has spent six years trying to repay the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Reservation for interest their water settlement money never earned. The Senate has passed the fix, a House committee approved its own version in October, and the clock on this Congress runs out Jan. 3.

The Duck Valley Reservation straddles the Nevada-Idaho line along the Owyhee River and is home to the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes. In 2009, Congress approved the Tribes’ water rights settlement as part of the Omnibus Public Land Management Act. The law ratified a Nevada agreement quantifying the Tribes’ federal reserved water rights, while a separate consent decree covered Idaho.

Where the money went The settlement promised $45 million for a development fund, mainly to rehabilitate the reservation’s federally built irrigation project, and $15 million for an operation and maintenance fund, according to 2021 testimony by then-Chairman Brian Thomas. Congress deposited the money over several years, but the Interior Department did not have authority to invest it until the settlement took full effect on Jan. 25, 2016.

Interior told Congress that, as a result, it returned to the Treasury all interest that had accrued before that date. The Tribes argued that the money meant to fix their irrigation system should have grown while it waited. Interior supported a legislative fix when the House considered one in 2021.

The fix The current Senate bill, S. 546, sponsored by Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto, would authorize $5,124,902.12 for deposit into the Tribes’ development fund. A Senate committee report describes that as the interest the funds would have earned on money deposited from Oct. 1, 2009, onward had investment been allowed.

The same fix has been introduced in Congress after Congress since at least 2020. The Senate passed an earlier version on Dec. 18, 2023, but it did not become law before that Congress ended. The Senate passed S. 546 by unanimous consent on Dec. 11, 2025.

The House version A House bill, H.R. 10306, was introduced on Sept. 8, 2026. The House Natural Resources Committee ordered it reported with substitute text by unanimous consent on Sept. 15, filed its report on Oct. 29 and placed the bill on the House calendar. If the House passes a version that differs from the Senate’s, the two chambers must agree on one text before it can go to the president.

Duck Valley is not alone. A separate Senate report in the same Congress proposes similar interest payments for three other Tribal water settlements approved in 2009 and 2010, covering the Navajo Nation, Taos Pueblo and the Pueblos in the Aamodt settlement in New Mexico. Each faced the same gap between deposit and investment.

The 119th Congress ends Jan. 3, 2027. If neither bill clears both chambers by then, the process starts over in the new Congress. Even after enactment, the law only authorizes the payment, so appropriators would still have to provide the money. The bill status pages on Congress.gov will show whether the House takes up the measure in the remaining weeks.


Discover more from KVIG Informative

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply