The Senate’s permitting overhaul rewrites the federal review Tribal Nations rely on to protect sacred places. The House decides next whether that rewrite becomes law.
The U.S. Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act on Nov. 19 by a vote of 62 to 33, according to the Senate roll call record. Five senators did not vote. The bill, known as BAAJA, now goes to the House.
Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., introduced the bill as S. 5653 on Sept. 30 with Sens. Mike Lee, R-Utah, Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., and Martin Heinrich, D-N.M. The four serve as the chairs and ranking members of the Senate Environment and Public Works and Energy and Natural Resources committees, according to the Congressional Research Service.
The Senate moved the text as a Capito substitute amendment to H.R. 2347, an unrelated House tax bill used as the legislative vehicle. Senators adopted that substitute 69 to 27 on Nov. 18, the roll call record shows.
BAAJA amends five bedrock laws: the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, the National Historic Preservation Act and the Federal Power Act. For Tribal Nations, the dispute centers on Division B, Title III, which rewrites Section 106 of the historic preservation law.
Section 106 requires federal agencies to account for how their projects affect historic properties before they spend money or issue permits. That includes places of traditional religious and cultural importance to Tribes. Agencies must consult with those Tribes whether the place sits on or off Tribal land, CRS reports.
As introduced, the bill would narrow which projects get reviewed at all, according to CRS. A project would qualify only if it needs a federal permit, license or approval and sits under substantial federal control. Projects whose only federal tie is a loan, grant or other financial assistance would drop out unless the money is for historic preservation.
The bill also narrows what counts as harm. CRS reports it limits adverse effects to direct, reasonably foreseeable ones and removes indirect effects. It drops feeling from the qualities of a historic property that agencies must weigh. Visual, atmospheric and audible intrusions would count only if they directly and significantly diminish the property.
New deadlines would govern consultation. Under the introduced text, an agency could move forward if a Tribal Historic Preservation Officer or other party fails to respond within 30 days to a request to review a report or finding, or if its objections are not substantive. CRS notes the bill does not define that standard.
Court challenges would change sharply. CRS reports that a judge who finds a Section 106 violation could only send the decision back to the agency, without voiding it or stopping construction. Preliminary injunctions for historic preservation violations would be barred, and suits would go to federal appeals courts within 150 days.
Tribes that file detailed comments during consultation would be exempt from some of the new limits on who can sue, according to CRS.
Tribal preservation programs would face federal evaluations at least every two years, with possible suspension of Historic Preservation Fund grants for noncompliance, CRS reports. The National Congress of American Indians reviewed the substitute on Nov. 8 and reported that the evaluations and grant suspensions remain, now with a corrective period, and that the limits on court remedies stayed in place.
The bill also carries money. As introduced, it authorizes $200 million a year for the Historic Preservation Fund from fiscal 2027 through 2036, up from the current $150 million a year drawn from offshore oil and gas receipts, but names no dedicated funding source, according to CRS.
It authorizes another $20 million a year from fiscal 2027 through 2030 for competitive grants to help Tribal Historic Preservation Officers build databases of culturally important places. CRS counted 235 approved Tribal historic preservation offices as of January 2026. NCAI said the substitute leaves Historic Preservation Fund deposits dependent on annual appropriations.
Supporters argue the Tribal title helps Tribes. An Oct. 8 analysis by Ben Schifman of the Institute for Progress, a Washington policy group, argued that BAAJA writes Tribes into Section 106 for the first time, keeps the law’s core Tribal consultation requirement and shields consultation from a pending rewrite of Section 106 rules by the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation. Schifman concluded the bill is more favorable to Tribal interests than current law.
Opponents read the same text differently. NCAI said the bill was written without a legislative hearing, committee markup or timely Tribal consultation, and urged senators to vote no. The National Trust for Historic Preservation said Nov. 8 it remains strongly opposed to the historic preservation title even as revised.
The House must pass identical text before the bill reaches President Donald Trump, whose budget office said Nov. 9 that his advisers would recommend he sign it. Whatever version survives will set the terms every Tribe works under when a pipeline, mine or transmission line crosses ground its people hold sacred.
Discover more from KVIG Informative
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
