Nevada’s Senators Split on BAAJA Over the Tribal Title

Jacky Rosen voted for the permitting bill at every key step. Catherine Cortez Masto broke away after the Senate kept historic preservation changes she said Nevada Tribes never helped write.

Nevada’s two Democratic senators ended on opposite sides of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. On final passage Nov. 19, Sen. Jacky Rosen voted yes and Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto voted no, according to the Senate roll call record. The bill passed 62 to 33.

The split opened a week earlier. Both senators voted Nov. 9 to end debate on taking up the bill, a motion that carried 73 to 25. On Nov. 16, when the Senate voted 70 to 27 to cut off debate on the authors’ substitute amendment, Rosen voted yes and Cortez Masto voted no.

Cortez Masto set her terms in a Nov. 9 statement. She said she would vote to begin debate but demanded that the Senate eliminate the bill’s changes to the National Historic Preservation Act, found in Title III, before final passage. She said she would not vote for the bill if Title III stayed in it.

She tied the demand to Nevada. Cortez Masto said Tribes in Nevada had concerns with the text, that the historic preservation changes were made without their input, and that the changes violate the federal government’s responsibility to consult with Tribes government to government.

Title III stayed. In a Nov. 19 statement, Cortez Masto said she voted against the bill because its changes to the historic preservation law undermine Tribal sovereignty and fail to protect government-to-government consultation. She said the passed version ignores Tribal input and that she was disappointed Republicans would not allow the section to be struck.

She also said the bill’s goals could be reached without threatening Tribal sovereignty.

The stakes run high in Nevada because so much of the state is federal land, about 80%, according to the Congressional Research Service. Mines, solar fields and transmission lines built on that land need federal approval, and federal approval triggers Section 106, the historic preservation review Title III rewrites.

Nevada has 20 federally recognized Tribes made up of 28 Tribal communities, according to the Nevada Department of Native American Affairs. Section 106 is the process through which federal agencies consult those Tribes about places of religious and cultural importance before a project goes forward.

Under the bill as introduced, those Tribes would face 30-day windows to respond to an agency’s reports and findings, and an agency could move past objections it does not consider substantive, according to CRS. A court that found a Section 106 violation could send the decision back to the agency but could not stop construction.

Tribes that file detailed comments during consultation would keep the right to sue, CRS reports, but a lawsuit would have to be filed within 150 days and heard in a federal appeals court.

Neighboring delegations split the same way. Arizona’s Ruben Gallego voted yes on final passage and Mark Kelly voted no. In New Mexico, co-author Martin Heinrich voted yes while Ben Ray Luján voted no, the roll call shows.

The bill now goes to the House, where Nevada’s four representatives will vote on the same Title III that divided the state’s senators. On roughly four of every five acres in Nevada, that title decides how much say a Tribe has before the bulldozers arrive.


Discover more from KVIG Informative

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply